Three Second Sol “Rules” for Virtual Sailing.

S4L Sec Sol Sailing the Catboat

The Second Sol Regatta begins June 14. Twenty teams are ready to compete in a total of 84 fleet races.

Before the start gun goes off however, I wanted to bring up three specific racing issues for the Patchogue II fleet.

Skipper/Crew Side-Switching Downwind

This issue primarily affects boats with a solo skipper. When sailing on a far broad reach or a run, the wind forces come from behind a boat and generate very little “heel.” A Patchogue II with a solo skipper will heel to the side where the skipper is seated.

However, Patchogue II likes to sail flat, with no heel. Often the only way a solo skipper can flatten the boat on a run is to first sit on the windward side until the boat heels too far in that direction, then move to the leeward side to bring the boat back past zero heel. The skipper then repeats the process, usually every 10-15 seconds. That maneuver can reliably produce a 5-8% speed boost by keeping the boat ‘balanced.’ However, this gain is so small that a skipper will probably only think to use it during a race.

heel waggle effect

Flat gives the best Boatspeed

There are several ISAF rules that prohibit non-wind methods of boat propulsion, including versions of tiller-waggling, sail back-winding, and crew weight-shifting.

However, I think a good argument can be made that skipper side-shifting in the Patch II is intended to enhance wind effects; side-switching downwind is therefore not an abnormal means of boat propulsion. Sailors who use this in Second Sol should not be penalized.

Rapid Reefing

Ronin Zane reports a similar effect with reefing upwind or on a reach. If a solo skipper or small number of crew sail a beam reach in a stiff breeze, they may often find that they have excess heel if they don’t reef. However, they may also find they lose too much speed when they add a reef point.

What’s the fix? Well, they can put all of the crew on windward rail, wait till heel is ‘too much,’ and then reef. That will right the boat back into the ‘go‘ zone. At the point the boat has a good heel angle, the the skipper can then free the reef again. That will cause the boat to accelerate and start to heel once more…

Ronin was concerned that repeated reefing might be illegal in a race, under the RRS Rules and guidelines against non-wind propulsion.

Ronin’s point is well taken. A real-life skipper would never change reef several times each minute. However, within the physical constraints of virtual sailing, in my opinion a sailor who tries to gain a small advantage by rapid-reefing is within his/her rights to do so. Reefing is a wind management tool, hence a racing technique. It’s not an exploit.

Equally important, recent Trudeau boats have a built-in reefing penalty. A boat will lose momentum for a few seconds with each reef change. That means any gain from ‘Rapid-Reefing’ is guaranteed to be small.

Having said that, let me again comment that although any rapid-reef benefit is small, in my opinion it’s legal.

Crew Alts

Ok ok, your crew doenn’t show up for the big match; what do you do? Well, it’s simple to rez a few of your favorite Alt-avatars, and use them to crew for you, Right?

Well Wrong. From every vantage I can think of, sailing with an Alt differs extremely from sailing with ‘human’ crew. I could write several pages on this topic, but I think I’d bore everyone to tears and put myself to sleep in the process. This is an obvious issue.

Bottom line, I think sailing with one’s own ALT in a race is illegal. (It’s probably also an abomination against man, god, and nature). Any skipper who deceptively races with their ALT in Second Sol should, by vote of the Judges, be DSQ for that race.

The above comments are just my opinions and apply only to Second Sol. I’m happy to hear other angles on these issues, and I’ll likely change my own view if someone makes a truly cogent argument over any of the ‘rules’ points raised above. 🙂

Patch2 engine trouble

Advertisements

4 responses to “Three Second Sol “Rules” for Virtual Sailing.

  1. Good points Jane. That brings up a question for me though.

    Can i use an alt when i have issues getting logged in with my avatar?
    So use an alt not to replace no show crew, but replace myself while armano can’t log in. It happens on a rare occasion sometimes.

    I think furthermore it’s hard to skipper yourself and move crew arround also
    when you’re both!

    • I think the practical answer is that an Avatar represents a person. If you need to log-in under a different name, that should be fine as long as it’s transparent. You just need to tell the RD and other sailors what you’re doing. (I’d think in the middle of a race you’d just need to yell “Hey!! It’s Really ME!!” 🙂 ). I know a few sailors who had special Avatars for regattas, to reduce the messages and other interference during a race. That was widely accepted, since everyone knew who was really sailing.
      The flip side to this issue occurs when a sailor enters multiple timeslots of a race under different Avatar names, hoping to ‘get lucky’ and win one of those groups. Because it’s deceptive, and breaks the trust inherent to a fair competition, I think that should be illegal. In fact, it should get the original sailor and all Avatars DSQ for that entire regatta series. (JMHO)

    • Armano said: “I think furthermore it’s hard to skipper yourself and move crew arround also when you’re both!”

      Actually, it’s not hard in a Trudeau. I edit the skipper hud and set it for “crew.” That way the HUD hike buttons move the crew, and the UpPage/DwnPage keys move the skipper. (but again, that’s just for testing or practice 🙂 ).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s